Almost everyone who thinks they don't like Marsala has only had the cheap 'Fine' version. The aged styles are entirely different wines. At Cantine Florio (Via Vincenzo Florio 1) or Cantine Pellegrino (Via del Fante 39) in Marsala, ask specifically for the Marsala Vergine or Superiore Riserva tasting, not the standard tasting which may default to Fine. Marsala comes in several styles: Fine (1 year, 17% ABV - the cooking ingredient), Superiore (2 years, 18% ABV - worth drinking), Vergine (5+ years, 18% ABV - the serious version), and Stravecchio Riserva (10+ years - comparable to aged Oloroso Sherry in complexity). Serve at room temperature or very slightly cool. The flavors are dried fruit, toasted nuts, orange peel, and a distinctive oxidative quality that rewards sipping slowly.
🔄 BACKUP: Both cantinas sell their aged Marsala for home. A bottle of Pellegrino or Florio Vergine is an extraordinary souvenir that few non-Sicilians have ever seen, let alone tasted.